INDUSTRY INSIGHTS YOUR PEERS ARE READING
And Internal Rate of Return (IRR)? Finance angel investment IRR ROI venture capital Flash: investors don’t believe your ROI projections. News at 11. Why is this news? It shouldn’t be. But recently I joined two other angel investor members of our local group in a conference call giving companies feedback on why they didn’t make the final rounds in our annual event. MORE
The definitive answer to these questions will come over time as our portfolio matures, our companies exit, and we can demonstrate a high cash to cash IRR. Fund managers are assessed, in part, on their ratio of expenses to assets under management. MORE
Our J Curve and early IRR may look worse than other funds. “What did you change about Homebrew III to better fit ‘seed phases’ versus seed rounds ?” a fellow VC asked me after my previous post. That’s a great question! MORE
You will not be moving your IRR needle enough by grabbing a few extra dollars in a marginal sale, but you will incur the wrath of a number of stakeholders who would be more than willing to spread the word far and wide about your greedy ways. MORE
Over the past 10 years their quarterly internal rate of return (IRR)—the primary measure of VC success—was dismal, hovering in the single percentage points and sometimes dipping into negative territory. Tags: Uncategorized VC IRR This piece in HBR is must read, it details why there will be a lot fewer VC funds in the future. The sky is falling on the venture capital rainmakers. MORE
Or if you’re a VC raising from LPs you have to list all of your deals, your investment value, your carrying value, your multiples, your IRRs, TVPIs, DPIs, etc along with net cashflows plus your previous LPAs. Why you should never have a data room?—?the MORE
So here's what the charts say for follow on strategies: If you run down the first column, what it says is that it basically doesn't matter if you follow on from an IRR perspective--a percent won't kill you here or there. Time is the enemy of IRR. MORE
VCs will be looking for a 10X return on their investment in 3 to 5 years, or 30% annual IRR (Internal Rate of Return). Too many entrepreneurs tell me they are looking for an investor, and can’t differentiate between venture capital (VC) investors versus accredited Angel investors. MORE
As an idea of how high the bar is for a GP, he says , “I dove into our fund log from the last couple of quarters and found that the mean IRR (among VCs listing one) was over 36%.” Historically, the process of winning capital from limited partners has been opaque. However, in the last few years a few have started to use social media and become more transparent. I particularly like OpenLP.com, SuperLP.com, and the Origins podcast. MORE
It’s not very often that angel networks disclose results. Most of us are ready and willing to discuss our approaches, beliefs or methods, but usually stop well short of providing the proof of our assertions. Today, Golden Angels is publishing. Funding startups MORE
You’re basically along for the ride with an investor who has very different incentives than you do – a different time frame, the AUM business vs IRR business, and requiring a scale in outcome that’s just astronomical. MORE
As Steve Case has said, it’s ridiculous that anyone can gamble and be guaranteed to lose money, but there are strict regulations around who can invest in early-stage private companies and earn (in some cases) a 27% IRR on their capital. *. MORE
Unfortunately as we’ve learned from recent experience, using Return on Net Assets and IRR as proxies for efficiency and execution won’t save a company when their industry encounters creative disruption. MORE
What is an IRR? Not all that glitters is gold. William Shakespeare. For many entrepreneurs “raising money” has replaced “building a sustainable business” as their goal. That’s a big mistake. When you take money from investors their business model becomes yours. MORE
Let’s get the fun part out of the way: the word coachability auto corrects to “coach ability” or “coach-ability” but I like it combined so I am running with it. MORE
The reality is that results in angel investing tend to bifurcate: “Professional” angel investors, who are investing calmly, steadily, relatively-rationally, over a long period of time and with a strong knowledge of both investment math and early stage realities, tend to not only make money, but do quite well: the average return for a comprehensive, well-managed angel portfolio is between 25% and 30% IRR. MORE
Sounds like a huge amount, but only later does he say that only " 476 funds which had known Net IRR values, the overwhelming majority of which were from vintage 2002, or more recently." 3) You can't eat IRRs for breakfast. You know what the IRRs of Quirky and Fab were before they went to zero? Looking at interim IRRs of young funds, especially during boom periods in venture isn't predictive of outcomes. MORE
Investors measure their success by looking at the internal rate of return (IRR). As an active angel investor, I’m accustomed to hearing entrepreneurs pitch their expectation to quickly create a new dominant brand, based on their disruptive technology. MORE
VCs will be looking for a 10X return on their investment in 3 to 5 years, or 30% annual IRR (Internal Rate of Return). Too many entrepreneurs tell me they are looking for an investor, and can’t differentiate between venture capital (VC) investors versus accredited Angel investors. MORE
My personal favorite in the “pure nonsense category” is the IRR, the Internal Rate of Return , something that was interesting for about one hour as part of the MBA curriculum, but which has no relevance in the real world. MORE
Another rule of thumb is a target of 50% IRR (a discounted cashflow calculation). If your startup desperately needs an investor, you may not care if the investor is a so-called “angel” investor, or a venture capitalist (VC). The money is the same color in either case. MORE
Based on the Wiltbank Study, investors should expect a 27% IRR in six years. We recently started a series of posts on establishing the pre-money valuation of pre-revenue startup companies for purposes of investment by seed and startup investors. The Venture Capital Method (VC Method) was first described by Professor Bill Sahlman at Harvard Business School in 1987 in a case study and has been revised since. MORE
The example he uses is: THE RAISE Investment $500,000 Pre Money $600,000 Post Money $1,100,000 OWNERSHIP Founders 55% Investors 45% EXIT Sale Price $5,000,000 Time 5 years INVESTOR RATIOS ROI 355% Multiple 4.55x IRR 35% NPV @ 10% $828,000 Admittedly that valuation and the resulting ownership causes me to wonder, but the most interesting aspect is that Bob is talking about investing in a much smaller exit, with no future investment planned. MORE
A common intermediary milestone for most investors is IRR (internal rate of return) of the fund. So there are a lot of unrealized gains built into the IRR of an early fund. Furthermore, we’ve established that companies don’t get credit for revenue — this does not get factored into IRR calculations. IRR calculations are based on two things — changes in a company’s value and the time-scale on which this happens. MORE
There is a rarified brand of successful investors who can show average IRRs of 25 percent or greater over the years. MORE
The Carmel I Fund, raised in 2000, had the highest performance, giving an internal rate of return (IRR) of 8% and a positive multiple of 1.4. Other funds, including Apax Israel II, Israel Seed IV and JVP showed negative IRRs of 20-30%. MORE
There is a rarified brand of successful investors who can show average IRRs of 25 percent or greater over the years. MORE
Our equity IRR has averaged around 50% since inception. I’m intensely proud of both the amazing startup community in Boulder as well as the many significant companies that have been – and are being – created in the little town of 100,000 people I call home. I regularly talk about the ones we’ve invested in through Foundry Group, but this only covers a part of the awesomeness that is going on here as Foundry Group has a very tight thematic focus. MORE
As Bill points out, many funds are sitting on huge paper gains which translate into large TVPI, MOC, gross IRR, or whatever the current trendy way to measure things are. Bill Gurley wrote an incredible post yesterday titled On the Road to Recap: Why the unicorn financing market just became dangerous … for all involved. It’s long but worth reading every word slowly. MORE
The good news for Techcrunch readers: Every major study conducted to date has placed angel investors’ IRR between 18 and 38 percent, as summarized by my Partner John Frankel and Professor Robert Wiltbank in prior Techcrunch articles. Every major angel study conducted to date has shown high IRR. I previously published this at Techcrunch. . MORE
What is an IRR? Not all that glitters is gold. William Shakespeare. For many entrepreneurs “raising money” has replaced “building a sustainable business” as their goal. That’s a big mistake. When you take money from investors their business model becomes yours. MORE
A consequence of using these corporate finance metrics like RONA and IRR is that it ‘s a lot easier to get these numbers to look great by 1) outsourcing everything, 2) getting assets off the balance sheet and 3) only investing in things that pay off fast. MORE
As a consequence, corporations used metrics like return on net assets (RONA), return on capital deployed, and internal rate of return (IRR) to measure efficiency. In the 21 st century it’s harder for large corporations to create disruptive breakthroughs. MORE
Having now invested in over 85 startups, and finding that my personal metrics are very similar to aggregated industry ones, it is clear that (a) there is little to no correlation between my home runs and my personal favorites, and (b) angel investing done correctly really *can* produce a consistent IRR in the 25%-30% range. MORE
The resulting fund would have an IRR in the range of 10% (the exact IRR would depend on the timing of the cash flows, but I constructed a few models to approximate this and 10% was the average return). MORE
By definition, IRR is calculated using amount invested, amount received at some point in the future, and time passed between the two cash flows. According to the Kauffman study “ Returns of Angel Investors in Groups ”, the mean IRR of angel investments hovered around 27% as of November 2007. MORE
Lets assume that Shylock Ventures is capable of producing a 20% IRR on a $100M fund. If Shylock Ventures were now to raise a $500M fund or a $1B fund, it probably will not be able to maintain its IRR. In my previous post , I claimed that “Venture Capital is a people business in every sense of the word. It is therefore a boutique industry and it cannot scale.” ” Let me expand on that thought a little more to qualify what I’m saying. MORE
But, when I make a bet on teams without pedigree, unless they are in a hot space, I know that they will have a really hard time raising money in the short term (and it will affect my short-term IRR as well). It really pains me to write this post…but it has to be said. MORE
But don’t quote me a damned IRR. As I write this in early 2019, I’m thinking back on more than 20 years of hearing business pitches as a judge of business plan competitions and as an angel investor. MORE
Another rule of thumb is a target of 50% IRR (a discounted cashflow calculation). If your startup desperately needs an investor, you may not care if the investor is a so-called “angel” investor, or a venture capitalist (VC). The money is the same color in either case. MORE
This LP is one of the more successful ones, they have positions in many of the top funds and have achieved a very comendable IRR from their investments in venture funds (well north of 20%, which is great as an average). One of the world’s larger investors in venture capital recently shared data with us about the multiples they have made on over 5,000 companies they had stakes in via their LP investments in US VC funds. MORE
There is a rarified brand of successful investors who can show average IRRs of 25 percent or greater over the years. MORE
The resulting fund would have an IRR in the range of 10% (the exact IRR would depend on the timing of the cash flows, but I constructed a few models to approximate this and 10% was the average return). MORE
September 5, 2016: Some recent successful exits in Austin have caught my eye for the relative simplicity of their business models. Patient… Continue reading on Austin Startups MORE
IRR Related Topics Tim Keane
OCTOBER 19, 2016
It’s not very often that angel networks disclose results. Most of us are ready and willing to discuss our approaches, beliefs or methods, but usually stop well short of providing the proof of our assertions. Today, Golden Angels is publishing. Funding startups
Austin Startup
AUGUST 31, 2016
September 5, 2016: Some recent successful exits in Austin have caught my eye for the relative simplicity of their business models. Patient… Continue reading on Austin Startups
Up and Running
JUNE 17, 2013
And Internal Rate of Return (IRR)? Finance angel investment IRR ROI venture capital Flash: investors don’t believe your ROI projections. News at 11. Why is this news? It shouldn’t be. But recently I joined two other angel investor members of our local group in a conference call giving companies feedback on why they didn’t make the final rounds in our annual event.
VC Cafe
MARCH 8, 2010
The Carmel I Fund, raised in 2000, had the highest performance, giving an internal rate of return (IRR) of 8% and a positive multiple of 1.4. Other funds, including Apax Israel II, Israel Seed IV and JVP showed negative IRRs of 20-30%.
Venture Chronicles
JUNE 30, 2010
Over the past 10 years their quarterly internal rate of return (IRR)—the primary measure of VC success—was dismal, hovering in the single percentage points and sometimes dipping into negative territory. Tags: Uncategorized VC IRR This piece in HBR is must read, it details why there will be a lot fewer VC funds in the future. The sky is falling on the venture capital rainmakers.
Gust
AUGUST 16, 2012
The reality is that results in angel investing tend to bifurcate: “Professional” angel investors, who are investing calmly, steadily, relatively-rationally, over a long period of time and with a strong knowledge of both investment math and early stage realities, tend to not only make money, but do quite well: the average return for a comprehensive, well-managed angel portfolio is between 25% and 30% IRR.
Gust
APRIL 30, 2014
Having now invested in over 85 startups, and finding that my personal metrics are very similar to aggregated industry ones, it is clear that (a) there is little to no correlation between my home runs and my personal favorites, and (b) angel investing done correctly really *can* produce a consistent IRR in the 25%-30% range.
Hunter Walker
NOVEMBER 13, 2018
You’re basically along for the ride with an investor who has very different incentives than you do – a different time frame, the AUM business vs IRR business, and requiring a scale in outcome that’s just astronomical.
Startup Professionals Musings
DECEMBER 16, 2017
There is a rarified brand of successful investors who can show average IRRs of 25 percent or greater over the years.
Steve Blank
MARCH 4, 2014
A consequence of using these corporate finance metrics like RONA and IRR is that it ‘s a lot easier to get these numbers to look great by 1) outsourcing everything, 2) getting assets off the balance sheet and 3) only investing in things that pay off fast.
This is going to be BIG.
JULY 30, 2015
So here's what the charts say for follow on strategies: If you run down the first column, what it says is that it basically doesn't matter if you follow on from an IRR perspective--a percent won't kill you here or there. Time is the enemy of IRR.
Startup Professionals Musings
FEBRUARY 5, 2018
Investors measure their success by looking at the internal rate of return (IRR). As an active angel investor, I’m accustomed to hearing entrepreneurs pitch their expectation to quickly create a new dominant brand, based on their disruptive technology.
This is going to be BIG.
MAY 16, 2016
Sounds like a huge amount, but only later does he say that only " 476 funds which had known Net IRR values, the overwhelming majority of which were from vintage 2002, or more recently." 3) You can't eat IRRs for breakfast. You know what the IRRs of Quirky and Fab were before they went to zero? Looking at interim IRRs of young funds, especially during boom periods in venture isn't predictive of outcomes.
Startup Professionals Musings
JUNE 5, 2015
There is a rarified brand of successful investors who can show average IRRs of 25 percent or greater over the years.
Startup Professionals Musings
MAY 9, 2014
There is a rarified brand of successful investors who can show average IRRs of 25 percent or greater over the years.
Startup Professionals Musings
AUGUST 2, 2014
VCs will be looking for a 10X return on their investment in 3 to 5 years, or 30% annual IRR (Internal Rate of Return). Too many entrepreneurs tell me they are looking for an investor, and can’t differentiate between venture capital (VC) investors versus accredited Angel investors.
Steve Blank
JUNE 23, 2016
As a consequence, corporations used metrics like return on net assets (RONA), return on capital deployed, and internal rate of return (IRR) to measure efficiency. In the 21 st century it’s harder for large corporations to create disruptive breakthroughs.
Steve Blank
JUNE 11, 2013
What is an IRR? Not all that glitters is gold. William Shakespeare. For many entrepreneurs “raising money” has replaced “building a sustainable business” as their goal. That’s a big mistake. When you take money from investors their business model becomes yours.
VC Adventure
AUGUST 12, 2014
The resulting fund would have an IRR in the range of 10% (the exact IRR would depend on the timing of the cash flows, but I constructed a few models to approximate this and 10% was the average return).
The Equity Kicker
MAY 27, 2015
The definitive answer to these questions will come over time as our portfolio matures, our companies exit, and we can demonstrate a high cash to cash IRR. Fund managers are assessed, in part, on their ratio of expenses to assets under management.
Startup Professionals Musings
JUNE 5, 2016
VCs will be looking for a 10X return on their investment in 3 to 5 years, or 30% annual IRR (Internal Rate of Return). Too many entrepreneurs tell me they are looking for an investor, and can’t differentiate between venture capital (VC) investors versus accredited Angel investors.
Up and Running
DECEMBER 22, 2015
My personal favorite in the “pure nonsense category” is the IRR, the Internal Rate of Return , something that was interesting for about one hour as part of the MBA curriculum, but which has no relevance in the real world.
VC Adventure
AUGUST 12, 2014
The resulting fund would have an IRR in the range of 10% (the exact IRR would depend on the timing of the cash flows, but I constructed a few models to approximate this and 10% was the average return).
Up and Running
MARCH 6, 2019
But don’t quote me a damned IRR. As I write this in early 2019, I’m thinking back on more than 20 years of hearing business pitches as a judge of business plan competitions and as an angel investor.
Steve Blank
JUNE 11, 2013
What is an IRR? Not all that glitters is gold. William Shakespeare. For many entrepreneurs “raising money” has replaced “building a sustainable business” as their goal. That’s a big mistake. When you take money from investors their business model becomes yours.
The Equity Kicker
OCTOBER 25, 2012
This LP is one of the more successful ones, they have positions in many of the top funds and have achieved a very comendable IRR from their investments in venture funds (well north of 20%, which is great as an average). One of the world’s larger investors in venture capital recently shared data with us about the multiples they have made on over 5,000 companies they had stakes in via their LP investments in US VC funds.
Startup Professionals Musings
APRIL 3, 2012
Another rule of thumb is a target of 50% IRR (a discounted cashflow calculation). If your startup desperately needs an investor, you may not care if the investor is a so-called “angel” investor, or a venture capitalist (VC). The money is the same color in either case.
Both Sides of the Table
MAY 19, 2018
Or if you’re a VC raising from LPs you have to list all of your deals, your investment value, your carrying value, your multiples, your IRRs, TVPIs, DPIs, etc along with net cashflows plus your previous LPAs. Why you should never have a data room?—?the
Gust
NOVEMBER 1, 2011
Based on the Wiltbank Study, investors should expect a 27% IRR in six years. We recently started a series of posts on establishing the pre-money valuation of pre-revenue startup companies for purposes of investment by seed and startup investors. The Venture Capital Method (VC Method) was first described by Professor Bill Sahlman at Harvard Business School in 1987 in a case study and has been revised since.
Feld Thoughts
APRIL 21, 2016
As Bill points out, many funds are sitting on huge paper gains which translate into large TVPI, MOC, gross IRR, or whatever the current trendy way to measure things are. Bill Gurley wrote an incredible post yesterday titled On the Road to Recap: Why the unicorn financing market just became dangerous … for all involved. It’s long but worth reading every word slowly.
David Teten
JANUARY 28, 2013
The good news for Techcrunch readers: Every major study conducted to date has placed angel investors’ IRR between 18 and 38 percent, as summarized by my Partner John Frankel and Professor Robert Wiltbank in prior Techcrunch articles. Every major angel study conducted to date has shown high IRR. I previously published this at Techcrunch. .
Feld Thoughts
JULY 31, 2013
Our equity IRR has averaged around 50% since inception. I’m intensely proud of both the amazing startup community in Boulder as well as the many significant companies that have been – and are being – created in the little town of 100,000 people I call home. I regularly talk about the ones we’ve invested in through Foundry Group, but this only covers a part of the awesomeness that is going on here as Foundry Group has a very tight thematic focus.
Hunter Walker
FEBRUARY 25, 2018
Our J Curve and early IRR may look worse than other funds. “What did you change about Homebrew III to better fit ‘seed phases’ versus seed rounds ?” a fellow VC asked me after my previous post. That’s a great question!
Berkonomics
OCTOBER 1, 2015
You will not be moving your IRR needle enough by grabbing a few extra dollars in a marginal sale, but you will incur the wrath of a number of stakeholders who would be more than willing to spread the word far and wide about your greedy ways.
Eric Friedman
MARCH 15, 2017
Let’s get the fun part out of the way: the word coachability auto corrects to “coach ability” or “coach-ability” but I like it combined so I am running with it.
SoCal CTO
MAY 19, 2010
The example he uses is: THE RAISE Investment $500,000 Pre Money $600,000 Post Money $1,100,000 OWNERSHIP Founders 55% Investors 45% EXIT Sale Price $5,000,000 Time 5 years INVESTOR RATIOS ROI 355% Multiple 4.55x IRR 35% NPV @ 10% $828,000 Admittedly that valuation and the resulting ownership causes me to wonder, but the most interesting aspect is that Bob is talking about investing in a much smaller exit, with no future investment planned.
Startup Professionals Musings
NOVEMBER 11, 2010
Another rule of thumb is a target of 50% IRR (a discounted cashflow calculation). If your startup desperately needs an investor, you may not care if the investor is a so-called “angel” investor, or a venture capitalist (VC). The money is the same color in either case.
David Teten
MAY 8, 2012
As Steve Case has said, it’s ridiculous that anyone can gamble and be guaranteed to lose money, but there are strict regulations around who can invest in early-stage private companies and earn (in some cases) a 27% IRR on their capital. *.
Steve Blank
MARCH 31, 2014
Unfortunately as we’ve learned from recent experience, using Return on Net Assets and IRR as proxies for efficiency and execution won’t save a company when their industry encounters creative disruption.
David Teten
NOVEMBER 17, 2011
By definition, IRR is calculated using amount invested, amount received at some point in the future, and time passed between the two cash flows. According to the Kauffman study “ Returns of Angel Investors in Groups ”, the mean IRR of angel investments hovered around 27% as of November 2007.
K9 Ventures
DECEMBER 14, 2008
Lets assume that Shylock Ventures is capable of producing a 20% IRR on a $100M fund. If Shylock Ventures were now to raise a $500M fund or a $1B fund, it probably will not be able to maintain its IRR. In my previous post , I claimed that “Venture Capital is a people business in every sense of the word. It is therefore a boutique industry and it cannot scale.” ” Let me expand on that thought a little more to qualify what I’m saying.
David Teten
MAY 16, 2017
As an idea of how high the bar is for a GP, he says , “I dove into our fund log from the last couple of quarters and found that the mean IRR (among VCs listing one) was over 36%.” Historically, the process of winning capital from limited partners has been opaque. However, in the last few years a few have started to use social media and become more transparent. I particularly like OpenLP.com, SuperLP.com, and the Origins podcast.
Hippoland
NOVEMBER 6, 2016
But, when I make a bet on teams without pedigree, unless they are in a hot space, I know that they will have a really hard time raising money in the short term (and it will affect my short-term IRR as well). It really pains me to write this post…but it has to be said.
74 
Let's personalize your content